The All-Time Scariest movies, ranked

Regan MacNeil (Linda Blair) shoots an unnerving stare towards the camera in The Exorcist

If you’re ever in the mood to see how spooky I found every movie reviewed as part of The All-Time Scariest, here is your handy listing right here! If you’re ever in the mood to eat a sandwich, I highly recommend a reuben.

Wandered here accidentally? Check out the primer on what The All-Time Scariest is all about. Remember, these ratings are not necessarily a reflection of how good these movies are, just how scary I deemed them to be!

0 paws out of 5

0 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system

0.5 paws out of 5

0.5 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system
  • The Cellar (1989), Kevin Tenney – Reviewed 6 October 2022
  • Evil Dead Rise (2023), Lee Cronin – Reviewed 31 July 2023
  • Scream (1996), Wes Craven – Reviewed 2 December 2024
  • Resident Evil (2026), Zach Cregger – Reviewed 1 October 2026

1 paw out of 5

1 paw print (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system
  • Nope (2022), Jordan Peele – Reviewed 15 August 2022
  • Smile (2022), Parker Finn – Reviewed 1 November 2022
  • The Thing (1982), John Carpenter – Reviewed 31 July 2025

1.5 paws out of 5

1.5 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system

Nothing yet! How eerie.

2 paws out of 5

2 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system

Nothing here, either! Positively ghoulish.

2.5 paws out of 5

2.5 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system
  • The Housemaid (2016), Derek Nguyen – Reviewed 12 October 2022

3 paws out of 5

3 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system
  • Talk to Me (2022), Danny Philippou, Michael Philippou – Reviewed 28 November 2023

3.5 paws out of 5

3.5 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system

Still yet to find one. Can you?

4 paw out of 5

4 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system

Still hunting for that 4 paw spook.

4.5 paws out of 5

4.5 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system

A rare scare… but where? Not there (yet)!

5 paws out of 5

5 paw prints (out of a possible 5), as used in EZIYODA's review system

The Exorcist (1973), William Friedkin – Reviewed 26 December 2023

Remember, if you’ve got any suggestions, let me know on Twitter!